























Notable features: Short scale; scalloped bracing; tortoise binding; dark guard; Brazilian bridge, fretboard, and peghead overlay. This 00-18 also has “pancake” tuner gears, plastic tuner buttons, an Ebony truss rod, and other wartime features.
Originality and repairs: 100% original except for the frets, nut, saddle, and bridge pins. Neck set and refret by Bryan Kimsey. Reglued braces, fret level/crown/polish and new saddle by me.
Much has been said about the batch of Red Spruce Marin was using in ’43, and this 00 shows the slight runout and banding that’s characteristic of the period. This year also has the wartime features that make it extremely light and resonant, and also quite fragile.
Notable features: Large fingerboard markers unique to ‘46, tapered bracing, tortoise binding, ebony truss rod, deep reddish-purple guard. Although not emphasized by the lighting in the photos, this is a good example of the stiff bearclaw Sitka from California that Martin used during this period. ’46 was also the final year that Martin used ebony fingerboards on this model.
Originality and repairs: 100% original except for the frets, nut, saddle, and bridge pins. Neck set, refret, minor bridgeplate and crack repair, and a new nut and saddle by David Musselwhite.
I purchased this guitar from the son of the original owner near my hometown in central PA. The seller’s mother bought the guitar new for the father’s birthday in 1947, and the guitar stayed in the family until I acquired it. The seller had the good sense to take the guitar to David Musselwhite before he sold it. David worked at Martin for decades, and has an acute knowledge of how a vintage Martin should sound and feel. David’s refret and setup capture the spirit of the original craftsmen.
This D-18 came with a 40s Gibson hard case, but the seller remembered the case from when he was a child, and was certain it was original to the guitar. I asked David about this, and he told me that during the war, dealers often sold Martin guitars in cheaper Gibson cases. Around the time I acquired this guitar, a ’44 Gibson J-45 found its way into my collection, and it came in an original 40s Martin case! When I sold the J-45, I sold it w/the Gibson case, and now I have an “original” Martin case for my D-18!
Notable features: All mahogany with original gloss finish; Brazilian bridge, board, and peghead overlay, scalloped bracing; original ivory nut; steel “T-bar” truss rod. This guitar was produced just a few months after the switch to the narrower 1 & 11/16” nut width.
Originality and repairs: Non-original brace and bridgeplate patch removed by Pat DiBurro, neck reset and new saddle by Terry Straker.
This is my one Golden Era Martin, and it has the deep, pillowy bass associated with Martin’s prewar models. The Mahogany top doesn’t have much headroom, but it has a surprisingly broad frequency range, and in some ways is more articulate than Spruce. This 00-17 has what I consider to be the gold standard of neck profiles. I’ve played no “vintage style” neck that captures the grace and of Martin's hand-carved necks from this era.
Notable features: 14-fret, straight bracing, wide nut, full V neck, original ebony nut, firestripe guard, 2-color burst, Red spruce top, probably basswood or "gumwood board, Brazilan bridge,
Originality and repairs: 100% original except for the frets and saddle. Refret by Chicago Fretworks.
This guitar dispels the myths about light builds and scalloped bracing. It’s not light, it’s straight braced, and it has the most mature, strident tone of any small-bodied vintage Gibson flattop I’ve played. My L-1 and Kel Kroydon are both much lighter, but neither is louder or fuller sounding. This is an effective live guitar with a bold tone that sounds every bit its age, and its thick mids work well with my Josephson C-42s.
Notable features: 14-fret, small 3-color burst, wide Ebony nut, double-bound, high-grade Red Spruce top, dark guard, scalloped bracing, original lacquered bridge
Originality and repairs: 100% original. Hairline cracks on top and back repaired with hot hide glue by me.
Collectors consider 1933 to be one of the best years for this model. The woods are top-notch, and the craftsmanship makes my L-00 seem crude by comparison. Among my vintage Gibson flattops, this L-1 has the most refined tone and feel. A Michigan social security number resides on the backstrip, presumably inscribed by the original owner who purchased the guitar from or near Gibson’s original Kalamazoo headquarters.
Notable features: 12-fret, extremely light build, Brazilian board, French polish Red Spruce top, original wide Ebony nut, thin neck profile, no truss rod
Originality and repairs: Back/sides refin by Folkway Music. Compression refret by Chicago Fretworks.
This extremely light and resonant 00-sized guitar was built by Gibson and marketed under the Kel Kroydon toy company brand. Some fingerstylists consider this to be the holy grail of fingerstyle guitars, and it’s the only steel string I’ve played on which I can produce a full, convincing tone with bare fingers. With its thin neck profile, lack of a truss rod, thin top, light finish, and “knife blade” bracing, the Kel is probably the lightest flat top ever built by Gibson. It is also a rare model, not only because few were produced, but also because few have survived due to their inherent fragility. (I’ve only played two others, and they both had serious structural issues.)
Notable features: 12-fret, short scale, Red Spruce top, straight-braced, 2 tone bars, wide string spacing, original 2”+ nut width, original huge neck carve, disoriented firestripe guard, original Grover tuners.
Originality and repairs: Flawless Spanish conversion from Matt Umanoff’s shop. Otherwise 100% original down to the bridge pins.
I became curious about these when I saw Duck Baker holding one on the back cover of The Art of Fingerstyle Jazz Guitar. When I was finally able to play one of these, I knew I had to have one, and I got lucky when the economy went south a few years back. The huge 75-year-old slab of Adirondack takes half an hour or so to warm up, but when it does, the sound is otherworldly. This guitar can cut through anything with a sweet, woody tone that is second to none in my collection. Undoubtedly the giant, stiff “V” neck has a lot to do with the tone, and this is as big as they get.
Notable features: 16” body, short scale, 1 & ¾” nut, Nick Lucas inlays, stained Maple back and sides, Red Spruce top, Brazilian board, shallow neck angle, bound fretboard and headstock, elegant "V" neck profile, 3-color burst.
Originality and repairs: 100% original, no repairs!
This guitar is usually associated with the statement, “I want to sound like Eddie Lang for under $10K”. This has all of the structural features of the Lang-era L-5, including the small body, the shallow neck angle, the fine Red Spruce top, and the sweet tone associated with this combination of features. The hand-carved neck has a graceful "V" profile that is a joy to hold. The sound is throaty but still sweet, perfect for solo arrangements.
Notable features: Original P-90, full-height Brazilian bridge, original tuners with buttons intact.
Originality and repairs: 100% original except for a new nut and refret by Chicago Fretworks.
These are true vintage "players". They are abundant, sturdy, relatively inexpensive, and have the greatest vintage pickup known to man. I bought this one from a farmer in Maine for $400 cash, which is the going price for the pickup alone. This Gibson has the most beautiful patina I’ve seen, with the possible exception of a ’50 LG-2 I owned. 1950 seems to be a good year for Gibson finishes.
Notable features: 12-fret, stamped F holes, thin-gauge steel body, original cone, original walnut finish
Originality and repairs: New ebony fretboard by NRP, neck set by Chicago Fretworks.
Like my D-18, this guitar came from central PA, very close to my hometown. There was no evidence of maintenance of any kind when I acquired it. Like most vintage NRPs, it needed a neck set, new fingerboard, and had too much neck relief. Fortunately, I own a ’35 Triolian that had the same work done by Marc Shoenberger, a tech who sets up NRPs for John Hammond and Bob Brozman, and is considered by many to be the best in the business. Using my ’35 as a model, Dan at Chicago Fretworks did a perfect restoration of the ‘29. We were very careful about setting up the guitar as it was designed, with the neck angle parallel to the body, and a shallow break angle behind the bridge. The new NRPs have a more aggressive neck angle and steeper break angle similar to a flat top. This setup (and its corresponding low action) seems to be what consumers demand, but I believe it puts too much string pressure on the biscuit and chokes the cone. This is just a theory, but my ‘35 setup by Marc, and this ’29 with an identical setup, sound better than any recent NRP I've played.
Notable features: Purple and orange burst; MOT fingerboard, headstock overlay, and guard; pyramid bridge; crude herringbone binding; fancy faux backstrip, period blue and yellow “guitar strap”.
Originality and repairs: Still working on that damn pickguard…
It probably goes without saying that any guitar with a purple and orange sunburst will be your wife’s favorite guitar, as is the case here. Neil Harp’s book does contain some ornate Stellas, but none quite as vivid as this example. Like all Stellas, this is a bear to play with its flat fretboard, but it has a huge, singing tone with a bottleneck. No wonder these were the choice of Charlie Patton and other Delta greats.
Notable features: All birch construction, original label.
Originality and repairs: All original save for a neck set, new nut, and new saddle.
This has one of the earlier Stella labels, and judging from the crude construction (even by Oscar Schmidt standards), this is quite an early Stella. It is a chore to play, but the reward is that inimitable husky Delta tone.
Notable features: Ash body, threaded steel saddles, 3-ply white guard, raised pole-pieces, top-hat switch tip, transition logo. Produced months before Fender switched to a poly finish.
Originality and repairs: All original except for the neck pickup. Small holes filled from a replacement bridge that once resided on the guitar.
This is the classic 60s Tele, the quintessential country guitar that exudes Roy Nichols and Don Rich. Boutique builders go to great lengths to replicate the gorgeous patina of this 45-year old nitro finish, including burying guitars in the yard, shooting them with flames, and other such nonsense.
Notable features: Peter Florance Broadcaster pickups, Swamp Ash body, Spaghetti logo, 5-hole Bakelite guard, steel saddles, “blend” wiring, slot-head screws, no diagonal route, one-piece maple neck with large “D” profile, single button string tree, other features consistent with a particular 1950 Broadcaster.
I acquired this guitar from an older gentleman I’ve swapped guitars with in the past. He owns a genuine 1950 Fender Broadcaster that he’s had for the better part of his life. Owning a $50K Fender is not always practical for gigs and rehearsals, so he had his Broadcaster studied and replicated by one of the most meticulous builders in the business, Mark Rutters. Mark is known for hand-machining saddles, bridges, knobs, and other Fender hardware to the pinnacle of vintage correctness. In fact all of the hardware on this guitar was hand-machined to precisely match the originals. The body is a stunning piece of very old Swamp Ash, and the craftsmanship is flawless.
Notable features: Lollar T-series pickups, white 7-hole guard, thin "Sonic Blue" nitro finish, brass saddles, high frets, switchcraft jack cup, Ash body, tone control that actually works.
This is an early K-line Tele built when Chris was still using Allparts necks. It’s my lightest and most resonant Tele, and makes a great rock guitar. I’m not sure who made the hardware, but it has an attractive steely, unfinished look even though it’s not relic’d. I’m particularly enamored with the tone control on this Tele, as it’s one of the few that has usable sounds through its entire sweep.